Deal breakdown · Hypothetical example

Would We Buy This $500K Airbnb?

A $73,800 gross revenue figure sounds strong on a $500,000 property. Here is what happens when we run it through the same structure we use for underwriting.

This is a hypothetical educational example. The property, rates, occupancy and costs are invented for illustration — not a real listing, market data or a client result.

Step 1

The hypothetical deal

Hypothetical deal assumptions
AssumptionValue
Purchase price$500,000
Down payment (25%)$125,000
Loan (7.25%, 30-year)$375,000
Annual debt serviceabout $30,698
Average nightly rate × booked nights$360 × 205
Gross revenue$73,800

Step 2

The full expense stack

Cleaning assumes a 3.5-night average stay and $150 per turnover (about 59 turns).

Hypothetical annual operating expenses
Annual expenseAmount
Cleaningabout $8,786
Management (15%)$11,070
Utilities and internet$7,200
Property tax$5,500
STR insurance$4,500
Platform fees (3%)$2,214
Maintenance and reserves (8%)$5,904
Supplies$2,800
Total operating expensesabout $47,974

Step 3

The result

Net operating income

≈ $25,826

Annual cash flow

≈ -$4,872

Debt service coverage

≈ 0.84

Cash-on-cash return

≈ -3.9%

Net operating income of about $25,826 does not cover $30,698 of debt service. The property loses roughly $4,872 a year before income taxes, closing costs, furnishing or anything this model leaves out.

Honest answer: not at these numbers.

Step 4

What would change the answer

Higher nightly rate. At $440 with the same 205 nights, gross revenue is about $90,200, cash flow is about +$7,264 and DSCR about 1.24. That only matters if comparable properties actually support $440 on booked nights.

Lower purchase price. Keeping $73,800 of revenue and the same loan terms, a price near $360,000 produces DSCR about 1.17 and cash flow about +$3,724. Reaching DSCR about 1.24 would take a price near $340,000 (cash flow about +$4,952).

Either path is a large gap from the asking price — which is the point of running the numbers before the offer.

Step 5

Stress test

Management (15%), platform fees (3%) and maintenance (8%) scale with revenue; cleaning scales with booked nights. Other costs and debt service stay unchanged.

Hypothetical stress-test scenarios
ScenarioGross revenueCash flowDSCR
Downside · 50% at $330≈ $60,225≈ -$13,9530.55
Base · 205 nights at $360$73,800≈ -$4,8720.84
Upside · 65% at $390≈ $92,528≈ +$7,6051.25

Only the upside case works. A deal that needs the upside to break even is a bet, not an underwriting result.

Step 6

What to verify before offering

  • Local STR rules, zoning, HOA restrictions and permit availability or transferability
  • Real comparable listings and their calendars — booked nights, not just listed rates
  • An actual STR insurance quote
  • Property tax reassessment at the new purchase price
  • Seasonality: how weak the quiet months really are
  • Quotes for cleaning, management, utilities and maintenance

Property-specific analysis

Want this done for a specific property?

The Full STR Acquisition Analysis ($249) combines market data, a full expense model, three scenarios and operator-reviewed judgment before you make an offer. See a sample report.

GET YOUR STR ANALYSIS — $249

Hypothetical educational example only. Not legal, tax, lending or investment advice.

Go Far STR Intelligence provides informational analysis and revenue projections only. Projections are estimates based on available information and assumptions and are not guarantees of future revenue or investment performance. This service does not constitute financial, tax, legal, lending or investment advice. Customers should independently verify zoning, permitting, HOA restrictions, insurance requirements, financing requirements and local short-term rental regulations before purchasing or operating a property.